JudgmentDeskTHE LAWYER’S DESK FOR INDIAN LAW
The Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, judgment by judgment
One judgment.
Three seats.

Landmark insolvency judgments of India, framed for every reader in the courtroom — a story anyone can follow, the law a lawyer can argue, and the craft even seniors miss. Pick your seat and climb.

Seat one

The Gallery

~5 minutes · no legal vocabulary

The case as a story — who wanted what, the twist, the verdict. Walk out able to tell it over dinner.

Seat two

The Bar

~12 minutes · for the practitioner

The questions, an interactive chart of the mechanism, and the holdings you may cite — in the Court’s own words.

Seat three

The Bench

Deep · the craft

The over-readings that trip up even seniors, both edges of the sword, and a live test on your own brief.

The Judgments

13 published · newest first
No. 13 · corporate guarantors & s. 10A NCLAT · 28.04.2023

Pooja Ramesh Singh v. State Bank of India

Comp. App. (AT) (Ins.) No. 329 of 2023 · the demand that landed in the COVID window

The borrower defaulted before COVID; the bank invoked the guarantee in October 2020. Under a deed payable on demand, the guarantor defaulted only when its seven days ran out — inside the section 10A window — so the petition against it was barred.

Read the judgment →
No. 12 · personal guarantors & revocation NCLAT · 06.01.2025

State Bank of India v. Gourishankar Poddar

Comp. App. (AT) (Ins.) No. 689 of 2024 · the guarantee he could not revoke

He resigned and wrote to the bank revoking his guarantee — then signed a new, irrevocable one. Letters the bank never accepted did not release him, his section 133 waiver held him to the lower figure, and the petition against him was in time.

Read the judgment →
No. 11 · corporate guarantors & limitation NCLAT · 26.04.2023

Archana Deepak Wani v. Indian Bank

Comp. App. (AT) (Ins) No. 301 of 2023 · the guarantor’s own date of default

The borrower defaulted in 2016; the bank came for its guarantor in 2020. Too late? Not when the deed waits for a demand: the guarantor is liable at once, but its limitation clock starts only after the bank asks it to pay.

Read the judgment →
No. 10 · personal guarantors & s. 95 NCLAT · 12.05.2026

Amit Bhatnagar v. UCO Bank

Comp. App. (AT) (Ins) 2038–2039 of 2024 · the Diamond Power guarantees

The group’s flagship was rescued and the banks took their payout — then came for the brothers’ ₹122 crore anyway. A plan that never mentions your guarantee does not release it, and an unchallenged DRT decree hands the bank a fresh limitation clock.

Read the judgment →
No. 9 · economic policy & judicial review SC · 23.03.2021

Small Scale Industrial Manufactures Assn. v. Union of India

three-judge bench · the COVID-19 loan moratorium case

A locked-down nation asked the Court to waive its loans. The answer: economic policy is almost court-proof — no total waiver, no forced extension — but interest-on-interest was struck for every borrower, and refunded.

Read the judgment →
No. 8 · guarantees & subrogation SC · 23.07.2024

BRS Ventures v. SREI Infrastructure Finance

2024 INSC 548 · two-judge bench · guarantees & subrogation

A parent rescued, a lender paid ₹38.87 crore, and a subsidiary still owing the balance. Why resolving the guarantor did not erase the borrower’s debt — and why buying the parent did not buy the subsidiary’s land.

Read the judgment →
No. 7 · s. 238A & limitation SC · 15.04.2021

Asset Reconstruction Co. v. Bishal Jaiswal

2021 INSC 254 · three-judge bench · the balance-sheet rule

A ₹6,000-crore claim the calendar seemed to have killed — and a tribunal at war with its own precedent. Compelled to prepare, never compelled to admit: the case that made a company’s own books exhibit one in every limitation fight.

Read the judgment →
No. 6 · s. 5(8) SC · 26.07.2021

Orator Marketing v. Samtex Desinz

2021 INSC 359 · the interest-free loan

A sister company’s ₹1.60-crore rescue at NIL interest — thrown out by two tribunals as not “financial” debt. Two words in the definition said otherwise: “if any”. The case that gave friendly loans a seat at the creditors’ table.

Read the judgment →
No. 5 · s. 10A SC · 09.02.2021

Ramesh Kymal v. Siemens Gamesa

Civil Appeal No. 4050 of 2020 · the COVID window

A ₹104-crore resignation, a petition filed three weeks before the ban existed — killed by it anyway. Section 10A runs on the date of default, not the date of filing: the case that fixed the COVID window for good.

Read the judgment →
No. 4 · ss. 8 & 9 SC · 21.09.2017

Mobilox Innovations v. Kirusa Software

the “existence of a dispute” test

A TV dance show, a ₹20-lakh bill, and one angry email from 2015. When does a real dispute stop an insolvency petition — and when is a defence mere bluster? The three questions every s. 9 case now begins from.

Read the judgment →
No. 3 · s. 238A & limitation SC · 22.10.2024

Vidyasagar Prasad v. UCO Bank

2024 INSC 810 · the balance-sheet acknowledgment

The bank knocked fifteen months after the deadline seemed to pass — and was in time. A settlement letter and one note in the company’s own balance sheet restarted the clock: how s. 18 acknowledgments really work under the Code.

Read the judgment →
No. 2 · ss. 7 & 32A SC · 19.01.2021

Manish Kumar v. Union of India

three-judge bench

Parliament built a gate on the homebuyer’s petition — 100 allottees or 10% — and a shield over rescued companies. Both survived. The Gate, the Shield, and the clock that decided who was caught in between.

Read the judgment →
No. 1 · s. 29A SC · 04.10.2018

ArcelorMittal India v. Satish Kumar Gupta

the Essar Steel bidding war

Who may bid for a bankrupt company? Two global giants, two hidden family skeletons, two eve-of-bid cover-ups — and the see-through provision that caught them both.

Read the judgment →

More landmarks are added as they clear the verbatim check — the collection grows case by case.

Why three seats

A judgment is read differently from every seat in the courtroom

The public hears a story. The bar argues the ratio. The bench watches for what everyone else missed. Most legal writing picks one audience and loses the others — each page here serves all three, at three depths, and lets you stop at any level with something complete.